She never expected the mystery boy from her anonymous midnight chats to be Beck, Hartwell’s star quarterback—and her best friend’s older brother. By the time Wren learns the truth, her heart is already in too deep. But when their secret is exposed, a leaked recording and an anonymous warning twist everything, leaving it to look like she meant nothing to him. With the whole campus watching, Wren must decide if she can trust what she’s been told—or the boy who fell for her first.