Everyone on campus knew Amelia Black as Tyler Pemberton’s hopeless admirer. When Tyler publicly confessed to another girl, everyone expected Amelia to break down—but she disappeared. Standing alone in the rain, she called Tyler’s colder, richer roommate, Damon Harrison. That night, she wore Damon’s hoodie and hid beneath his blanket while Tyler searched nearby. Amelia remembers her previous life: Tyler destroyed her, but Damon was the one who buried her. This time, she chooses Damon first. What will Tyler do when he discovers the girl he rejected belongs to the one man he cannot defeat?